Players who played for both the San Francisco 49ers and the Indianapolis Colts

Easy to name

Common and Uncommon. The easiest answers between these two teams.

• Frank Gore

  RB · 2005–2020 · SF 2005–2014, IND 2015–2017

  Common

• DeForest Buckner

  DL · 2016–2026 · SF 2016–2019, IND 2020–2026

  Common

• Walt Harris

  DB · 1996–2008 · SF 2006–2008, IND 2002–2003

  Uncommon

• Richard Dent

  DL · 1990–1997 · SF 1994, IND 1996

  Uncommon

• Samson Ebukam

  LB · 2017–2026 · SF 2021–2022, IND 2023, 2025

  Uncommon

• Antoine Bethea

  SS · 2006–2019 · SF 2014–2016, IND 2006–2013

  Uncommon

• Arden Key

  DL · 2018–2026 · SF 2021, IND 2026

  Uncommon

• Pierre Garcon

  WR · 2008–2018 · SF 2017–2018, IND 2008–2011

  Uncommon

In the middle

Real answers, but not the first ones people think of.

• Rock Ya-Sin

  DB · 2019–2026 · SF 2024, IND 2019–2021

  Rare

• Tavon Wilson

  SS · 2012–2021 · SF 2021, IND 2020

  Rare

• Cassius Marsh

  DE · 2014–2021 · SF 2017–2018, IND 2020

  Rare

• Charvarius Ward

  DB · 2018–2026 · SF 2022–2024, IND 2025–2026

  Rare

• Marlon Mack

  RB · 2017–2022 · SF 2022, IND 2017–2021

  Rare

• Brian Hoyer

  QB · 2009–2023 · SF 2017, IND 2019

  Rare

• Jeremy McNichols

  RB · 2017–2026 · SF 2017, 2023, IND 2018

  Rare

• Donald Strickland

  CB · 2003–2011 · SF 2006–2008, IND 2003–2005

  Rare

• Bubba Paris

  OL · 1990–1991 · SF 1990, IND 1991

  Rare

• Sheldon Day

  DL · 2016–2025 · SF 2017–2019, IND 2020

  Rare

• Josh Johnson

  QB · 2008–2025 · SF 2014, 2022, IND 2015

  Rare

• Aubrayo Franklin

  NT · 2003–2013 · SF 2007–2010, IND 2013

  Rare

• Trey Sermon

  RB · 2021–2025 · SF 2021, IND 2023–2024

  Rare

• Matt Gay

  K · 2019–2026 · SF 2025, IND 2023–2024

  Rare

• Mike Adams

  DB · 2004–2019 · SF 2004–2006, IND 2014–2016

  Rare

• George Odum

  DB · 2018–2026 · SF 2022–2024, IND 2018–2021, 2025

  Rare

• Kemoko Turay

  DL · 2018–2022 · SF 2022, IND 2018–2021

  Rare

• Ricky Jean Francois

  DE · 2009–2018 · SF 2009–2012, IND 2013–2014

  Rare

• Hassan Ridgeway

  DL · 2016–2023 · SF 2022, IND 2016–2018

  Rare

• Samuel Womack

  DB · 2022–2025 · SF 2022–2023, IND 2024

  Rare

• Gino Torretta

  QB · 1993–1997 · SF 1995–1996, IND 1997

  Rare

• Doug Brien

  SPEC · 1994–2005 · SF 1994–1995, IND 2001

  Rare

• Zach Kerr

  DT · 2014–2021 · SF 2021, IND 2014–2016

  Rare

• Chase McLaughlin

  K · 2019–2026 · SF 2019, IND 2019, 2022

  Rare

• Mark Thomas

  DL · 1992–2001 · SF 1992–1994, IND 1998–2001

  Rare

• Tim Hauck

  DB · 1990–2002 · SF 2002, IND 1998

  Rare

• Briean Boddy-Calhoun

  DB · 2016–2020 · SF 2020, IND 2019

  Rare

• Khalil Davis

  DL · 2020–2024 · SF 2024, IND 2021

  Rare

• Khalid Kareem

  DL · 2020–2026 · SF 2026, IND 2022

  Rare

• Jason Baker

  SPEC · 2001–2011 · SF 2001–2002, IND 2004

  Rare

• T.Y. McGill

  DT · 2015–2024 · SF 2022–2024, IND 2015–2016

  Rare

• Matt Pryor

  OL · 2018–2026 · SF 2023, IND 2021–2022

  Rare

• Monty Montgomery

  DB · 1997–2004 · SF 1999–2000, IND 1997–1999

  Rare

• Alan Grant

  DB · 1990–1994 · SF 1992–1993, IND 1990–1991

  Rare

• Chris Hetherington

  RB · 1996–2006 · SF 2005–2006, IND 1996–1998

  Rare

• Jose Cortez

  SPEC · 1999–2005 · SF 2001–2002, 2005, IND 2005

  Rare

• Mike Cofer

  SPEC · 1990–1995 · SF 1990–1993, IND 1995

  Rare

• James Parrish

  OL · 1991–1996 · SF 1993, IND 1993

  Rare

• Scott Tolzien

  QB · 2011–2017 · SF 2011–2012, IND 2016–2017

  Rare

• Darryl Morris

  DB · 2013–2017 · SF 2013, IND 2016

  Rare

• Ian Silberman

  G · 2015–2018 · SF 2015, IND 2017

  Epic

• Nate Hobgood-Chittick

  DL · 1998–2002 · SF 2000, IND 1998

  Epic

• Mike Person

  T · 2011–2019 · SF 2011, 2018–2019, IND 2012, 2017

  Epic

• Kyle Nelson

  LS · 2012–2021 · SF 2014–2020, IND 2021

  Epic

• Tony Blevins

  DB · 1998–2000 · SF 1998, IND 1998–2000

  Epic

The rarest links

The players almost nobody names first, and the biggest bonus in a puzzle.

• Michael Brandon

  DL · 1993–1996 · SF 1995–1996, IND 1993

  Epic

• Isaiah Williams

  OL · 2017–2021 · SF 2020, IND 2017

  Epic

• Colin Cloherty

  TE · 2009–2011 · SF 2010, IND 2009

  Epic

• Shane Andrus

  K · 2009–2010 · SF 2009–2010, IND 2009

  Epic

• Cam Johnson

  LB · 2012–2016 · SF 2012, IND 2013

  Epic

• Shane Bonham

  DL · 1994–1999 · SF 1998–1999, IND 1999

  Epic

• Rob Murphy

  OL · 2000–2004 · SF 2003–2004, IND 2002

  Legendary

• David Wilkins

  DL · 1992–1996 · SF 1992, IND 1996

  Legendary

More 49ers matchups

49ers and Bears · 49ers and Bengals · 49ers and Bills · 49ers and Broncos · 49ers and Browns · 49ers and Buccaneers · 49ers and Cardinals · 49ers and Chargers · 49ers and Chiefs · 49ers and Commanders · 49ers and Cowboys · 49ers and Dolphins · 49ers and Eagles · 49ers and Falcons · 49ers and Giants · 49ers and Jaguars · 49ers and Jets · 49ers and Lions · 49ers and Packers · 49ers and Panthers · 49ers and Patriots · 49ers and Raiders · 49ers and Rams · 49ers and Ravens · 49ers and Saints · 49ers and Seahawks · 49ers and Steelers · 49ers and Texans · 49ers and Titans · 49ers and Vikings

More Colts matchups

Colts and Bears · Colts and Bengals · Colts and Bills · Colts and Broncos · Colts and Browns · Colts and Buccaneers · Colts and Cardinals · Colts and Chargers · Colts and Chiefs · Colts and Commanders · Colts and Cowboys · Colts and Dolphins · Colts and Eagles · Colts and Falcons · Colts and Giants · Colts and Jaguars · Colts and Jets · Colts and Lions · Colts and Packers · Colts and Panthers · Colts and Patriots · Colts and Raiders · Colts and Rams · Colts and Ravens · Colts and Saints · Colts and Seahawks · Colts and Steelers · Colts and Texans · Colts and Titans · Colts and Vikings