Archive

NFL Puzzle #52 recap: Ben Roethlisberger to Billy Ray Smith Jr.

This NFL puzzle ran on Sep 23, 2026. The task was to connect Ben Roethlisberger to Billy Ray Smith Jr. with a chain of real players. The objective: “Your chain must include an Oklahoma State alum.” Par was 3 links.

The Start: Ben Roethlisberger

Ben Roethlisberger (QB) played in the NFL from 2004 to 2021. A one-team career, spent with the Pittsburgh Steelers (2004 to 2021). College: Miami (Ohio). Honors in the dataset: Offensive Rookie of the Year. As the Start of the chain, a household name like this gives you a lot of teammates to branch from, which makes it a friendly place to begin.

The Finish: Billy Ray Smith Jr.

Billy Ray Smith Jr. (LB) played in the NFL from 1990 to 1992. A one-team career, spent with the Los Angeles Chargers (1990 to 1992). College: Arkansas. As the Finish of the chain, a household name like this gives you a lot of teammates to branch from, which makes it a friendly place to begin.

Ben Roethlisberger and Billy Ray Smith Jr. do not share a team or a college, so there is no direct link. You need at least one connector in between, and the objective decides which ones are allowed to count.

How the objective shapes the route

This was a college objective. The chain has to pass through a player from the named school at some point, not necessarily as a link to the Start or Finish. Of the 17,979 players in the pool, 148 satisfy it. The best known are Reggie White (RB, 2001), Barry Sanders (RB, 1990 to 1998), Tyreek Hill (WR, 2016 to 2025), Thurman Thomas (RB, 1990 to 2000), Kevin Williams (DT, 2003 to 2016), and Dez Bryant (WR, 2010 to 2020).

8 of those players share a team or college with Ben Roethlisberger, and 5 share one with Billy Ray Smith Jr.. The Finish is the tighter side, so it often pays to work backward from Billy Ray Smith Jr..

Show a 3-link solution (spoiler)

One shortest chain found by searching the full player pool, preferring the best known names at every step:

  1. Ben Roethlisberger (QB), the Start
  2. Jerome Bettis (RB), linked to the previous player through Pittsburgh Steelers
  3. Leslie O'Neal (LB), linked to the previous player through Los Angeles Rams
  4. Billy Ray Smith Jr. (LB), linked to the previous player through Los Angeles Chargers

Many other chains work. Scoring rewards lower-profile connectors, so the best-known route is rarely the highest scoring one.

Want more? Browse the full NFL puzzle archive, read the strategy guides, or see how scoring works on How to Play.